

Like a Friday night fish fry
or that first sip of an Old Fashioned at your favorite supper club or savoring that beer brat in the shadow of Lambeau Field. We believe in things that last. Things that matter. Like showing up when you say you will. Building something strong enough to hand down. Or keeping your word.
That’s the old-fashioned way. And that’s where our story begins.
We’ve seen what happens when legacy gets lost. When purpose gets replaced by profit. When people become numbers. But here’s the thing about folks raised on food on a stick at the State Fair, borrowed snowblowerss and squeaky cheese curds —you don’t just let something good slip away. Not without a fight. So we chose to hold tight to what mattered, and we knew it meant starting over.
We rallied as one, starting with Dustin Nelson, a former Army Infantry officer, always prepared to fight for what is right even when it is hard. Dustin White, not chasing contracts, but honoring commitments. Mel Russell, the steady voice of integrity, making sure our message stays true. Catherlina Klineschmid, keeping the culture’s heartbeat alive. Jordan Steinberg, where loyalty does not come easy but man does he have it down. And Matt Suson, a Marine who’s never just stood by when something worth protecting was at risk.
Old Fashioned Roofing is your local roofing company that wasn’t built to be the biggest in Wisconsin. Just the most trusted. The most honest. The most human. From your local business to your home. We cheerish every opportunity to prove that the old ways are still the preferred ways.
Welcome to Old Fashioned Roofing. Where a handshake still matters and your word still means something. Where we value every heartbeat and where the traditions that raised us will raise this company too.
You know, the Old Fashioned Way.

OFR in a Nutshell

Dustin Nelson
Owner - Captain of the Ship - Co-CEO
Former Airborne Ranger – United States Army. Dustin grew up on Midwestern work ethic and hasn’t looked back since. With a background in operations, sales, and strategic leadership, he brings structure and long-term vision to Old Fashioned Roofing. Dustin’s passion lies in building something that lasts — not just great roofs, but a culture grounded in trust, accountability, and purpose. He’s a legacy-builder at heart, and every job is a chance to live that out.

Dustin White
Owner - Roofing Guru - Co-CEO
Dustin is our commercial roofing specialist and field operations lead. With deep experience in flat roofing systems, service agreements, and complex commercial projects, he knows how to keep things running tight and right. If it’s big, flat, and needs to last — Dustin’s your guy.

Catherlina Klineschmidt
Owner - VP of Operations
Catherlina is the steady presence every good company needs. She’s organized, dependable, and holds the line on doing things the right way. Whether it’s behind the scenes or on the front lines of customer care, she helps make sure Old Fashioned Roofing runs like it should — with pride, precision, and a personal touch.

Melbourne Russell
Owner - Chief Marketing Officer
Mel is the voice behind the brand and the one who makes sure people know exactly what Old Fashioned Roofing stands for. With years of marketing experience and a sharp eye for strategy, he keeps the message honest, consistent, and unmistakably Wisconsin. Whether it’s a billboard, a website, or a handshake at the State Fair, Mel helps us show up the right way.

Jordan
Project Manager/Consultant
If you hear bootsteps on the roof, it’s probably Jordan. Known for his reliability, precision, and the fact that he’s never without his cowboy boots, Jordan brings a seasoned, no-nonsense energy to the team. With a strong background in roofing and a deep personal connection to the industry, he’s someone who takes pride in doing things the right way — no shortcuts, no excuses.

Matt
Project Manager/Consultant
Matt is the kind of guy who brings grit to the job site and a groan-worthy pun to the lunch table. A National Guard Marine with a sharp work ethic and a knack for keeping morale high, Matt does more than just show up — he shows up ready. Whether he’s on the roof or keeping the crew laughing with one of his legendary dad jokes, Matt is a reminder that hard work and good humor go hand in hand.

Addie
Office Administrator Extraordinaire
Addie keeps the whole operation humming. From scheduling and paperwork to keeping crews on track and customers in the loop, she’s the steady hand behind the scenes. Friendly, fast, and sharp as a tack, Addie makes sure nothing falls through the cracks — all with a smile and a mug of strong coffee. If you’ve called our office, you’ve probably already experienced her magic.